Police: 75-Year-Old Suffocated Wife, Tried To 'Cover Tracks'

Police: 75-Year-Old Suffocated Wife, Tried To 'Cover Tracks'

Posted: Updated:
PHILADELPHIA -

Philadelphia police say the 75-year-old husband charged with murdering his wife intended to kill her, first tried to pin the attack on a neighbor and then "tried to cover up his own tracks."

Capt. James Clark, of the police department's Homicide Unit, said 75-year-old husband Lou Hartdegen has been formally charged.

It was an unbelievable twist in the case, but police said during a news conference Tuesday that good detective work led the husband to confess.

"There were a lot of red flags," Clark said. "I won't get into them, but I will just say that he tried to out-slick us, and he did not."

Police responded at 2:50 a.m. Monday to a reported burglary in progress inside an apartment on the 6700 clock of Castor Avenue in Northeast Philadelphia.

Judith Hartdegen, 74, was found on her bed, and she was pronounced dead at the scene.

Her husband, who said he suffered some bruises and scratches to his face, originally told police that someone broke into the residence.

"Preliminarily, Mr. Hartdegen told the police that his neighbor had entered his apartment through a rear window, sexually assaulted and suffocated his wife, then beat him and then fled from that location," Clark said.

As the community mourned the woman killed in what was thought to be a home invasion, word came that the story actually unfolded much differently.

"Because of great detective work by some very homicide detectives – who found several discrepancies in his statement – along with that information, they went to Mr. Hartdegen, who then gave a full statement that he had made up the entire story and that he, in fact, during a domestic argument with his wife had struck her several times and he had suffocated her."

Clark declined to go into too much detail on those discrepancies, except to say that they were between the husband's statements and the way that the crime scene was laid out.

Police said the wife was not sexually assaulted, and her husband's injuries were the likely result of her attempts to fight him off.

Police say Hartdegen was known to them, but Clark declined to say if they'd been to the home before.

A 26-year-old neighbor was questioned for several hours, based on Hartdegen's statement, but that man was eventually released when "the right information came to the forefront," Clark said.

Neighbors are stunned by the turn of events. FOX 29's Dave Schratwieser will have more details in live reports on the FOX 29 News at 5 & 6.

WATCH LIVE: FOX 29 News At 5 & 6

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • 75-Year Old Woman Hurt During Purse Snatching At South Jersey Shopping Center

    75-Year Old Woman Hurt During Purse Snatching At South Jersey Shopping Center

    Friday, August 22 2014 11:02 PM EDT2014-08-23 03:02:06 GMT
    "I'm shocked because I come here all the time and I've never had an issue ever and never felt unsafe," said Christina Polizzi of Cherry Hill. She is one of many shoppers atThe Promenade shopping Center on Route 73 in Eveshamhorrified to hear that a 75 year old woman was critically hurt from a man who snatched her purse. "That's horrible, that's horrible," said Polizzi.It happened Wednesday night around 8:30. Police say the woman was walkingwhen a man came up alongside her and violently grabbe...
    "I'm shocked because I come here all the time and I've never had an issue ever and never felt unsafe," said Christina Polizzi of Cherry Hill. She is one of many shoppers atThe Promenade shopping Center on Route 73 in Eveshamhorrified to hear that a 75 year old woman was critically hurt from a man who snatched her purse. "That's horrible, that's horrible," said Polizzi.It happened Wednesday night around 8:30. Police say the woman was walkingwhen a man came up alongside her and violently grabbe...
  • Local Military Family Behind 'Goodbye Monsters' Book, Protector

    Local Military Family Behind 'Goodbye Monsters' Book, Protector

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:00 PM EDT2014-08-23 02:00:16 GMT

    A South Jersey veteran and his wife responded to bedtime fears with a new book called "Goodbye Monsters," and it comes with a protector!

    A South Jersey veteran and his wife responded to bedtime fears with a new book called "Goodbye Monsters," and it comes with a protector!

  • Clerk Shot During Wilmington Liquor Store Robbery

    Clerk Shot During Wilmington Liquor Store Robbery

    Friday, August 22 2014 6:38 PM EDT2014-08-22 22:38:37 GMT
    A surveillance camera catches it all as two workers at Cutrona Liquors in Wilmington struggling to keep a gunman out of their North Market Street shop.
    A surveillance camera catches it all as two workers at Cutrona Liquors in Wilmington struggling to keep a gunman out of their North Market Street shop.
Powered by WorldNow
Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices